الفهرس | Only 14 pages are availabe for public view |
Abstract This thesis presents the results of a research study on the shear behavior of Ultra High Strength Concrete (UHSC) beams. The study aims to investigate the shear behavior of UHSC and verify the applicability of current code provisions to determine the minimum shear reinforcement of higher concrete strengths. Seven UHSC beams were cast and tested under two concentrated vertical loads to study their shear behavior. Furthermore, three High Strength Concrete (HSC) and three Normal Strength Concrete (NSC) were cast and tested to evaluate the adequacy of ECP minimum shear reinforcement requirements. Three main factors were studied to investigate the behavior of the tested beams. These factors are: • Concrete Compressive Strength (fcu). • Amount of transverse reinforcement (ρw). • Amount of steel fiber (Vf). The scope of the study consisted of an experimental investigation and finite element analysis. The experimental program was conducted at the Properties and Testing of Material Laboratory of the National Housing & Building Research Centre. The results of the experimental program were presented and discussed. The theoretical phase included a numerical study to investigate the shear behavior of the tested beam specimens. In the first section of this phase, the experimental results were used to calibrate the finite element models. Then in the second section, the calibrated model was used to estimate some complex data to be measured experimentally. 7.2 Conclusion The following conclusions were drawn from the results of the research program: 1. Shear capacity and midspan deflection in UHSC beams increased with the increase in the volume fraction of steel fibers by 29% and 43%, respectively. 2. The use of steel fibers led to (a) an enhanced inclined cracking pattern (multiple cracks), (b) more ductile shear failure, and (c) an increase in the stiffness of the beam. Chapter (7) Summary & Conclusions ــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــ 3. Increasing the concrete strength caused an increase in the shear capacity of beams with and without stirrups. For example, for specimens with identical shear reinforcement spacing, increasing the concrete strength from 48 MPa to 83 MPa caused an increase in the shear capacity by about 14%, while increasing the concrete strength from 83 MPa to 128 MPa caused an increase in the shear capacity by about 25%. 4. The beams with a more significant amount of stirrups (that is, lower spacing of stirrups) failed with the formation of diagonal cracks with closer widths. On the other hand, beams with fewer shear stirrups (that is, higher spacing of stirrups) failed with the formation of diagonal cracks with wider spacing. Further, in the case of stirrups with lower spacing, the shear load capacity and midspan deflection of UHSC beams were higher. 5. Diagonal crack width has been influenced by both the amount of shear reinforcement and concrete compressive strength. As a result, the diagonal crack widths for specimens with identical shear reinforcement spacing are almost similar, although shear strength and the number of cracks. 6. Test results indicated that adding steel fibers enhanced cracking loads, ultimate loads, shear strength, and the ductility of the studied beams. For example, adding 1% fibers by volume increased the cracking load by about 25% and the ultimate load by about 31% over the reference beam. 7. It was found that a combination of web reinforcement and fibers resulted in obtaining the benefit of both high capacity and ductility. This combination resulted in a significant increase in the ultimate loads by 25% over those of the reference beam specimen. The addition of transverse shear reinforcement can modify the failure mode from a brittle shear to a ductile flexural failure mode. 8. By adding steel fiber to beams with transverse shear reinforcement, redaction in crack width has been observed by 80%. In addition, the fibers appeared to be effective in delaying the formation of cracks. 9. Comparing the experimental results with the equations used for calculating the ultimate shear capacity of UHSC beams given in ACI 318-19 [45] and the Egyptian code for concrete structures ECP 203-17 [58], it was found that the ACI code equations give preferable calculated shear capacity than Vn calculated using the ECP 203-17 equations. The ECP needs reassessment to include the effect of higher concrete compressive strength. 10. The ECP 203-17 [58] requirements for minimum shear reinforcement are not satisfactory when UHSC and HSC are used. Test beams having ECP 203-17 minimum shear reinforcement had less reserve shear strength than the others, and the crack width observed at the stage of shear cracking was beyond the allowable serviceability limits. 11. The equation proposed in this paper requires approximately 35% more minimum shear reinforcement than ECP 203-17. Beams designed using this equation had a significant increase in reserve shear strength index by 53% than beams having ECP Chapter (7) Summary & Conclusions ــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــ 203-17 minimum shear reinforcement, and crack width remained below the allowable serviceability limits (< 0.30 mm). Specimens having the minimum shear reinforcement following the proposed equation satisfied the criteria set in this study. 12. In respect of reserve strength is the most important parameter in determining the minimum shear reinforcement (which depend on concrete tensile strength). It would be more reasonable and rational to derive the equation by equating the magnified cracking shear strength to the ultimate shear strength. When this is done, the following equation is obtained, where the coefficient C is related to reserve strength. 𝐴𝑣𝑚𝑖𝑛 𝑏𝑤𝑠 = 𝐶 𝑓𝑡 𝑓𝑦 13. The finite element program gives conservative values for the diagonal shear cracking loads concerning the experimental diagonal shear cracking loads. 14. There is a good agreement between the failure loads obtained from the finite element analysis and those obtained from the experimental results for the all-beam specimens. 15. There is a good agreement between the deformations obtained experimentally and theoretically. 16. The predicted stirrups strain values are well correlated to the experimental values. At the same time, the FEM underestimate longitudinal steel strain values for UHSFC beam specimens. However, the curves show good agreement with the experimental findings for the rest of the beam specimens. 7.3 Recommendations for Future Research 1. Studying the behavior of UHSC beams under pure torsion stresses and the combined effect of direct shear and torsion. 2. Studying the effect of using UHSC on the long-term deformations of beams. 3. Studying the behavior of UHSC beams under the effect of cyclic loading. |